|Mallard||"Play Something Country" by Brooks & Dunn||SAFE|
|Caterpillar||"It's Gonna Be Me" by N-SYNC||SAFE|
|Queen of Hearts||"River" by Bishop Briggs||SAFE|
|Banana Split||"Let 'er Rip" by the Chicks||SAFE|
|Beach Ball||"Party in the U.S.A." by Miley Cyrus||ENTER + ELIM|
- Taco from Season 3 made a cameo appearance at the beginning of the episode.